The Alien Earth series has been widely discussed for both its strengths and notable flaws, resulting in polarizing reviews among fans and critics. The primary issues center on poor character decision-making, continuity troubles with the larger Alien franchise, unresolved storylines, and controversial characterization, particularly of the lead hybrid character Wendy.
Major Problems Identified
- Character Decisions
Many critics argue that the series suffers from the “idiot ball” trope, where nearly every character makes perplexing and uncharacteristically foolish choices throughout the episodes. Trained scientists and crew members repeatedly act irresponsibly—such as leaving dangerous alien containers unsecured—prompting frustration among viewers who expect higher competence on a critical mission. - Continuity With Franchise
The show complicates existing Alien series lore and timelines, introducing new types of artificial lifeforms and major events (like a Xenomorph on Earth) that don’t fit well with previously established continuity. Fans have noted these issues muddy the franchise’s canon instead of clarifying it, reducing the uniqueness and impact of the earlier films in the series. - Lead Character Controversy
Wendy, the hybrid lead, is at the center of criticism for being a “Mary Sue”—a character portrayed as always smarter, braver, and stronger than everyone else, with no apparent weaknesses and the ability to command Xenomorphs. This has led to accusations of one-dimensional writing and an imbalance in character development compared to others in the story. - Production and Cast Issues
Controversies around cast participation also surfaced, such as Sydney Chandler (who plays Wendy) missing a major promotional shoot due to personal discomfort with a scheduled video segment, creating a PR incident for the series prior to its premiere. - Unresolved Storylines and Cliffhangers
The series finale has been criticized for providing a cliffhanger rather than a satisfying conclusion, leaving fans feeling deprived of closure after a season of building tension and mystery.
Points of Praise
- Visuals and Performances
Despite its narrative shortcomings, Alien Earth is praised for high production values, effective creature design, nostalgic ambiance, and some strong performances—particularly Sydney Chandler in the role of Wendy. - Expansion of Alien Lore
While some expand-on-the-canon choices are divisive, certain fans appreciate the new context and sci-fi concepts the series introduces, believing it brings a fresh perspective to the iconic franchise.